When is a gift of information not a gift?
IMHO if you wish to genuinely give (hopefully) useful information / updates etc, then these should be donated it within the framework of the Horizons site.
Unless, of course, the Hubb is just being used to redirect traffic elsewhere for selfish aka $$ / promoting self importance etc. reasons.

Would it not be useful if Grant/Susan could share their detailed views on what is/is not acceptable?

Why should one be limited to the HU framework ?

I am glad people share links to interesting sites, blogs, products and video's.
As far as I know, that is the purpose of the HUB, to share information in any form.

__________________
Jan Krijtenburg

My bikes are a Honda GoldWing GL1200 and a BMW R1200GS

My personal homepage with trip reports: https://www.krijtenburg.nl/
YouTube channel (that I do together with one of my sons): motormobilist.nl

Gift of information is always a gift.
If there is a specific question being asked, and I know of YouTube video or article/blog that covers the subject, I link to it. I don't spend time to write my own answer, or copy/paste from the other location. I have also linked to well made manufacturer videos (like making carbon fiber panels) when the method can also be applied to products from other manufacturers.
If I was making some things (parts, videos, etc.), and someone asked about that sort of things, I would say that I am making those things. I would probably also put a link in my signature. I would not link to them and say they were the best thing on earth, and I would not have that as my only contribution to the forum.
So now you have my opinion, for what it's worth.

Linsk to your own Youtube channel should not be allowed.
Since that is commercial advertisment: Forbidden.
Evenif it is travel story.
HU should not be used to get more viewer/subscribers/money.
Youtube channels are money makers.

But....
of course if someone else has published an instruction video that answers a specific queastion. That is OK.

a) It is not you own channel => you do not earn on it
b) It answers a question and is not used for general advertisment


That is my personal opionon.
Others have differnet views. And that is OK for me.

Welcome to the Hubb
Just a quick heads up on your post
If you manufacture goods to sell on here, you need to get in touch with Grant/Susan to pay your advertising dues before you advertise on here. They'll welcome your contact.
ATB

AFAIK know linking pages with advertising or affiliate links is against HuBB rules.

I had a link to a non travel, non commercial page I used to run in my signature when I joined and had to remove it as it was against rules. I'm not aware things have changed.

From the Forum FAQ

'You agree not to post any advertising, URL's with affiliate id's or tracking numbers or anything which actively promotes your own site or company without prior authorization. Pretending to be a traveller and hyping your own business is not okay. '

I don't really have any problems with Grant's rules. After all it's not a democracy, it's his site, so he can decide what's acceptable and what's not. And most of the time it is fairly cut and dried - this link is some chancer being paid to promote something = snip. That link is someone wanting free advertising = snip. The other link is trying to drive traffic to an eg YouTube channel / clickbait site where eyeballs mean money = snip.

At the other end there's links that come up in the course of valid discussions - 'here's what I mean', or 'this is what I used'. Many of those end up at commercial sites but they're not snipped, mainly, I'd guess anyway, because there's no direct commercial gain being made - it's mainly an exchange of information. That, when all is said and done, is what we come here for. Questions and answers, freely peergroup given.

But, as always, there are grey areas. Links to personal YouTube sites, posts that start off as 'here's my experience in South America / Africa / Road of Bones' etc and end 'my book of the trip is now on Amazon', 'Big Names' that pop up with a fairly bland post aimed at keeping them in the public eye, references in the text to other people's commercial sites, people who put a bit more effort in than just a mild profanity and a link, and all the rest. All of which could fall one side of the line today and the other side tomorrow. I got my personal travel site snipped many years ago and my wrist slapped for including it in my signature even though it had no money making content whatsoever and was purely for entertainment, yet I notice other have not. Maybe they've contributed, but I was never asked for money, just told to remove it. Maybe a different moderator on a different day would have reached a different conclusion but it was what it was and that's the rules we play by. I used to think the balance point was 'here's something I did' = snip, but 'here's something he did' (that I think is relevent to the topic and I'm not making any money out of it) = tick, but it's obviously more nuanced than that.

I guess things are different over on HU Facebook where a lot of the contributions are blatently nothing but self promotion. If you snipped them there wouldn't be much left.

I do notice that there are far fewer verbal fist fights these days than there used to be. Whether that's the smack of firm moderation - a sort of snip first and sort it out afterwards approach, or that we're just a nicer bunch of people these days I can't tell (probably we're all older!) but it certainly has made it a more pleasant place to 'hang out'.

I think you are far away from reality if you state YT channels are generally money makers.

Google tells me that are 38 millions YT chanels existing and that every minute these users upload 500hrs of content. 230.000 channels have more than 100k subscribers. 22.000 channels got more than 1 million subscribers. 700 of them have over 10 Mio subscribers.

You need a minimum of 1000 subscribers and you must have reached a minimum of 4000 watched hours in the past 12 months before you can start monetizing your channel. If you reached this than the CTR(Clickthrough rate) ist coming to the game: You get a 100 views on a video and 5 user click an ad. Gives you a CTR of 5% which is the value that is monetizing. A video like this would you make earn some less cents.

So to state a YT chanel is a money maker will be for the majority of YTs still a dream that never drives into the reality of money making. Growing the amount of monthly subscribers and views through valuable content is hard work and it takes normally years to get some money back. Not everybody in the scene of motorcycle videos is a Noraly from Itchey Boots who was able to create an explosive channel wonder. And btw she has a lot of subscribers from regions with a with a very low CPM. Which means simply explained that indian viewers don`t create as much ad value as european users do and which reduces clearly her income measured only by the numbers of viewers compared to channels with western viewers. (a reason why she offers subtitles in many languages)

I totally agree if someone registers a The Hubb and tries to use the forum only to start selfpromoting his channel - that this should be stricltly forbidden.

But if there is a member who contributed to the social community here and who now starts a travel vlog why should he/she not to be permitted to give this information to the community?
In todays times YT is what the books in the 18th century were and nobody would state generally that books should be forbidden because the writer could makes eventually money on it.

I think that the contributing community here as well as the owner with his forum rules and moderating actions are doing a realy great job which donesn`t need any strictly ban to YT channels of members.

If I look to the stats I get the info that HU website has an average of 3155 unique users with 9466 pageviews a day. And because you can read the forum without any registrations an easy way to stop abusing this plattform as a multiplier for your YT channel or ad/afiliate websites will be to generate a script that blinds out out all links in comments for not logged in users. But be aware this will also have an negative effect to the stats and ad income of HU website and it would possibly damage the over years build up image and value of this openhearted and helpfull community.

So I think the rules of HU are still fine and all members create a valuable community which does not need more strictly bans than existing today. We are all guests here and as a guests and people who travel the world we are used to follow the rules given by the host or don`t we?

__________________

Think some of you are making a mountain out of a mole hill !!
It is a great site !
#
If it bothers you so much then dont "U TUBE "

I think some have missed the point, sharing useful info is often a great help, but a user who just posts linking his blog to earn revenue rather than provide useful info isn't in the spirit of the hubb imho.

The updates I've been providing on the COVID situation are posted on 2 other sites that I run, now I could just post a link to one or both of those sites, but thats against the rules so I post the info here as a new comment in the appropriate forum. I gain nothing from posting here or elsewhere except the knowledge that people may find the information helpful.

I very much disagree with that.
I put links to my TouTube channel on the HUB, not to make money (with the few views I get I don't make money anyway) but to share the experience of the things I love to do (motorcycle rides) with others.
Youtube channels only are moneymakers if you have thousands of viewers and even if they are moneymakers for some peoeple, if the video's are interestings, why not share them on the HUB ? You don't have to watch them and you don't have to pay for it so why would you care.

__________________
Jan Krijtenburg

My bikes are a Honda GoldWing GL1200 and a BMW R1200GS

My personal homepage with trip reports: https://www.krijtenburg.nl/
YouTube channel (that I do together with one of my sons): motormobilist.nl

My take is that you are not and have not used the Hubb to promote your channels.
For me that's absolutely fine and I have zero issues with you attaching links in your signature.
Some, however, constantly promote their channels. Either for a monetary reason (quite rightly against the rules). Or through some sort if hubris/self gratification (just plain boring and tedious

If you don't like it, don't watch it. There is enough other content on the HUB.

__________________
Jan Krijtenburg

My bikes are a Honda GoldWing GL1200 and a BMW R1200GS

My personal homepage with trip reports: https://www.krijtenburg.nl/
YouTube channel (that I do together with one of my sons): motormobilist.nl

I don't think that he was referring to your content as being boring or tedious - but he finds the way that some people constantly self promote their channels - you don't do that.

__________________
You will have to do without pocket handkerchiefs, and a great many other things, before we reach our journey's end, Bilbo Baggins. You were born to the rolling hills and little rivers of the Shire, but home is now behind you. The world is ahead.