As a very late comer to the topic, and a serial thread killer, I should probably not contribute, but I am oh so bad at making the right choices.
I didn't enjoy it, not out of any deap seated jealousy (honest) or moral misgivings, just because it is very badly made.
The camerawork was generally horrible, the voiceovers grating, the focal points badly chosen, and the 'talent' incredibly annoying. Ewan was likable enough to justify his 'celebrity,' but HOW innane and whingey is his spoilt child of a boyfriend!? Immature and simple, and the 'energetic and mischevous rogue' persona he tries so hard to project just ends up as retarded child for me.
The two 'suits' travelling in the support cars were by far the biggest flaw of the experience though. Their attitude turned it from the purported adventure of a lifetime into an over structured expedition. One of their comments at the end was something along the lines of.
'I'm glad it's over, but I'm also a little bit sad,'
This says everything about their motivation, it was just a job for them. If I was E or C, I would never have employed that sort of man for such a trip. Conversely, Claudio seemed to have a great attitude, very easy going and adventure spirited - but got much less screentime than he did in LWR?
It is a format of television that depends heavily on the personalities of those involved, which is why Michael Palin has done so well in this arena. I just can't empathise with any of the characters (which is essentially what they are, as several people have stated - this may as well be a soap opera.) To an extent, Ewan can carry the others with his charisma and superior celeb status, but this is not enough. Who would want to carry Char;ie very far, or either of the overstuffed suits for that matter.
At the end of the day it was successful, so what do I know?
We all know that a lot of that success comes from Tarquins with limited edition LWD Snap On Toolboxes parked beside their Landrover though.
Happy Riding.
Joel