|
Best type of tank bag?
It's been years since I last was in the market - and much have changed. Two new bikes - and I need some advice.
Layered style I've looked at the Mosko Moto Nomax (on web only, not in real life). 6 layered compartmentalization, charging ports, room for hydration bladder, back pack configuration - it seems awesome! I really like the idea of having a back-pack that I can use for shopping or trekking. I also want the option to carry an easily accessible fleece jacket, some gloves maybe, and a camera. Will a layered style backpack work for this? Rigid bucket with hood This type seems very convenient while on the go - no hurry to zip up. Simply open the lid and grab whatever, or toss in whatever - and go - and zip shut when convenient. You sacrifice compartmentalization. As a backpack it might not be as good. Soft bucket This is what I have had in the past. One big room with a map pocket in the lid. One small pocket on each side and one facing me - very convenient. Expandable - convenient. What I did not like was that the bag became floppy unless completely filled. It was not even remoteley waterproof, and dealing with a separate rain cover is something I prefer to avoid for as long as possible. I've never had a back pack configruable bag in this category, but missed it. Floating, Strapped Mount vs Magnetic Magnetics is a no go for me on any bike - due to chafing and how poorly I assume it will sit on more agressive riding - also my GF's tank on her 390 Adventure is plastic. On the T7 I don't know as I am still waiting delivery. The floating kind - ihow well does it work offraod? I like how easily it comes on and off, and that it doesn't chafe. On the Tenere 700, that has no tank ring, it requires a rig that not only looks very funky, but one which I do not trust. I may go down this route for my GF's 390 who probably would prefer a rigid bucket. The strapped kind - it will cause chafing for sure, but not as bad as the magnetic I presume. Dealing with the straps is convenient enough for me. This is likely the route I will go on the T7. I am leaning towards the Nomax - if the many compartments have enough give to accomodate larger items in one. Other desireable features
Advice please Bucket with hood or layered with many compartments and organization features, or something else? Volume? What is a good allround volume - for both trips and every day use closer to home? |
I'm also in the market for a tank bag. Never used one before. I looked at the Nomax, but it seems like it's not waterproof.
Would (also) love to hear recommendations. Are there any good waterproof tank bags? |
I have been very happy with my Enduristan 4H.
IMO its well designed, with attention to fit and finish. I've been through enough storms and its always remained dry inside. Two thumbs up from me https://enduristan.co.uk/collections/tankbags |
I like Baglux, they do bike specific harness for a range of models which protects the tank really well and a good range of bags to go on them, they also do some universal harness which I have also used and work well.
|
Apart from the different designs - the size is important.
I bought a F650GS twin a while ago that included the BMW tank bag for this bike. For road trips it was quite useful, good volume and (probably) waterproof. For off-road rides it was a pita. Far too wide to ride the bike while standing on the foot pegs :( |
My advice will be less useful to the OP since I'm not focusing on offroad performance, but...
My go-to system has been the Givi Tanklock. Have a small 3D6-series bag, 3D603 I guess, which holds my chargers, papers like ferry tickets and things, a bottle of water - basically quick-access stuff. Very easy to take off for access to the tank at a gas station, has a shoulder strap for convenient carrying off the bike. Essentially anything I care about losing is in that bag, which I always take with me - the stuff in the panniers is all replaceable. The one I have is not 100% weatherproof, but it took riding through a MAJOR downpour - for a long time - for the zipper seam to fail. |
I found this bag locally:
https://www.amazon.com/Givi-Gravel-T.../dp/B07NF2N7F9 I don't know if it was their last one and they wanted shelf space. But I only paid 55 euros instead of the 100 listed on amazon. I tested it in the shower and seems to be 100% waterproof. I feel very lucky and pleased with my purchase. |
Givi the best of the lot. Magnets and straps are almost totally obsolete these days.
|
I'm a big fan of the Giant Loop Fandango tank bag.
I don't actually have that tank bag, because my current tank bag works good enough, but if I were going to get one, I would go with the Giant Loop Fandango model. It has organizers inside. You can zip it on and off of its harness which seems like a great feature for camping when you want to take inside your tent with you. It would also work well for hotels. |
SW motech
I am happy with my SW Motech Evo System.
But now they have an improved system PRO Series. With more flexible mount. And magnet assisted. Select mount for your bike. And select a bag according to your need/preference https://adventuremc.se/sv/tankvska-pro-serien.html https://www.sw-motech.info/en/media/...k_Bags_EN.html |
My 2013 Enduristan 2S is still in use and I bought a two-generations-on 4S for the UK.
https://cdn.shopify.com/s/files/1/00...g?v=1562679566 My priorities were totally waterproof and an interior colour other than black so I could actually find things in the bag! |
Quote:
Are any of the ring attached tank bags waterproof? |
I'm a total convert to the tank bags that clip onto a tank ring. No more messing around with straps.
A good magnetic one (without straps) comes a close second as long as you have a big metal tank. My tankbag (can't remember brand), also has an SAE Connector extension built into it. Making charging your phone/camera/powerbank on the go really easy. |
I know that posting this is tempting fate. I have an Enduristan bag. I had a Givi tank ring bag as well. The zip on the Givi failed, so I cannibalised it for it’s tank ring attachment and used this attachment on the Enduristan bag. This involved perforating the underside of the bag. So far, even in very heavy rain, it hasn’t leaked, and it has been secure on the tank ring.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk |
Waterproof
If 100% waterproof is top priority.
Take a look at this: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nnbDQJfCbiU The more "useful" bags with small pockets/zippers are convenient. But not water proof. O have never got external cover to work. => With the later type of bag => All things in that bag has to be in small plastic bags. It is a trade off. |
Quote:
Although for older bikes with metal tanks that Baglux don't make a cover for then I have an Oxford Sports magnetic bag which works well. |
Quote:
|
Quote:
Sent from my SM-G781B using Tapatalk |
consider this
That any fitting tank bag costing less than the eye-watering asking price of $260:rolleyes2: can work fine and you can make it waterproof with one of a huge range of weigh next to noting waterproofing bag.
Especially when the GL states marketing blurb announces that: "Both tank bags are designed be fully waterproof when used with the included Dry Pod inner liner."doh it isn't waterproof on its own. Save your money for fuel and shop around- loads of second hand ones out there. or go buy one on amazon here for 'only' £269.23... import fee included but not UK VAT it seems which could make it £323.07- you could get 2 new tyres for less than...a bag! |
I use the Mosko Moto Hood tank bag: https://moskomoto.eu/collections/mot...32853828141135
Ideal, fully waterproof without a cover, couple of useful internal bags or on its own, it's large enough to take a DSLR or similar camera with a decent lens and the single buckle is easy to operate even with winter gloves on. I'll never again buy a tank bag that's not waterproof without an additional cover. |
Without IRL experience, from the specs and looks, the Mosko Nomax and the Mosko Hood are both at the top of my wish list. I can't decide which one I prefer, maybe because I am looking for different features for different trips.
What I like about the hood is that it has one decent size compartment, has rigid sides and a lid which all makes it is easy to both rumage through and to toss things into - even in flight. One large space accommodates for a greater selection of items - i.e. tossing in a small grocery bag when the rest of your luggage is back at camp. One large compartment comes at the expense of organization through many smaller - but plastic bags, pouches and Tupperware takes care of this (in some ways better than pockets do). What I like about the Nomax is that it also serves as s backpack. Also, although not a rigid style, many pockets keeps the bag firm and doesn't floop too much around when not full. More importantly, whenever I am to leave the bike unattended for more a minute, I like to take along my "all day carry items" and valuables (electronics, keys, paperwork, money, sunglasses, etc). An easy portable back pack style tank bag is perfect for this. I also like to have a backpack that can hold a few shopping items when I run errands. Although a bit on the small side, the Nomax seems adequate enough. How good is the hood for carrying around? |
| All times are GMT +1. The time now is 11:22. |