Horizons Unlimited - The HUBB

Horizons Unlimited - The HUBB (https://www.horizonsunlimited.com/hubb/)
-   Northern and Central Asia (https://www.horizonsunlimited.com/hubb/northern-and-central-asia/)
-   -   russian police (https://www.horizonsunlimited.com/hubb/northern-and-central-asia/russian-police-55907)

geordy paul 5 Mar 2011 17:09

russian police
 
ive been reading lots of threads, posts and trip reports while planning my trip, seems like the police can be a problem.
apart from sticking to the rules of the road, is there any advice on how to deal with them when we get stopped? most advice ive seen so far is about haggling the size of fine/bribe.
paul

Jake 5 Mar 2011 17:43

Ive been to Russia a few time and never once been stopped or harassed by the police and i did pass plenty police cars and checkpoints. Lithuania the Police were a bit aggressive and wanting a bribe but I just kept smiling handed them my in order papers and never made any offer of a bribe I was let on my way after a short delay. I ws also stopped by a russian army patrol who mainly wanted cigarettes - as I dont smoke I had none then after a look around the bike and a bit of broken conversation - I was on my way. Maybe I was lucky or maybe others have been unlucky. Keep within the speed limits, smile a lot if stopped and have all your papaers in order and ready to check. Make sure everything on your bike is working and correct. In my opinion its not as corrupt as people make out.

colebatch 5 Mar 2011 18:13

Russia is much less of a problem than surrounding countries like Ukraine or Kazakhstan, where they often make up offences, to extort bribes.

In Russia these days, if you get pulled over its either for a routine document check or because you genuinely broke a road rule. The most common offences are speeding and crossing a solid single white line in the middle of the road. If you break a road rule, then you have to be prepared to pay the fine. Just like anywhere else in the world.

Fortunately in Russia there are two advantages to being caught breaking road rules than in your home country:
(1) You dont lose any points
(2) You get the option of paying a 50% reduced penalty if you pay direct to the policeman, and dont ask for a receipt.

Note, if you decide NOT to take advantage of the second benefit, then you will not only have to pay the full fine, but you may also get to spend 2-3 hours with the Russian traffic police while they process your paperwork. They are unlikely to be thrilled at this prospect and therefore may choose to see if there are any other problems with your paperwork while they are at it. i.e. if you make it hard for them, dont expect them to want to make it easy for you ...

In contrast, the process of paying the "reduced penalty" is relatively straight forward. You sit down in the back of the police car, put your payment together inside your documents (drivers licence and registration papers) and hand them all together to the traffic cops.

They will return your paperwork about 5 seconds later (less the cash) with a smile and an "everything is in order, you may go sir".

Note, speeding is a relatively minor offence in Russia and a relatively small penalty. Crossing a white line is more serious and will be more expensive.

colebatch 5 Mar 2011 18:27

Drinking and Driving in Russia
 
As an afterthought ...

Russia is FAR MORE STRICT on drinking and driving than Western Europe. Until very recently the only acceptable blood alcohol concentration was 0.00%.

That has been ever so slightly relaxed, such that trace elements of alcohol from yesterdays drinking are less likely to cause a problem. But if they see people on bikes drinking a beer at lunch, dont be surprised to see them waiting for you down the road.

Most Russians I know will not even drink non alcoholic beer, because if they get pulled over, it still smells like beer to the traffic police, and that can still lead to several hours with the police and a blood sample or two being taken, before they are confident enough to believe you that it was non-alcoholic beer.

As a rule of thumb in Russia and surrounding states ... drink ONLY after you have finished the days riding.

Even the discount rate penalty for driving with alcohol in your blood will cost you about 1500 - 2000 EUR.

Edit: everytime I wrote b-e-e-r it comes up as beer.

Andysr6 5 Mar 2011 23:58

Hi, I have travelled in many Eastern European countries inc Moldova, Ukraine & Russia and have never had any problems, whenever stopped in Russia at local check points a flash of my passport usually got you waved through. Andy

motoreiter 6 Mar 2011 05:28

Colebatch is 100% correct. The Russian police "problem" is greatly exaggerated, it is really not that big of a deal if you follow Colebatch's pointers.

The best thing to do to avoid speeding to simply follow the locals' que. If everyone slows down, you should too. Also, Russian drivers are quite good about flashing their headlights for oncoming drivers when they pass a police car on the side of the road.

Again, as Colebatch says, crossing a white line is a big no-no, so don't do it. This can be frustrating because Russian roads are slathered in no-passing zones for no apparent reason. Nonetheless, I've found that if you wait a bit, Russian drivers will often edge to the right of their lane, leaving enough space for you to pass them without crossing into the other lane, or at least you can pass them ON the white line. I've never been pulled over as a result.

Finally, to repeat Colebatch again, don't ever drink and drive, the Russians check quite frequently, and if you are caught with any amount of alcohol, you're ****ed. If you can get of out trouble at all (not certain), it will cost you very dearly.

geordy paul 6 Mar 2011 09:19

police
 
thanks for the replies,
eased a few concerns, one guy i spoke to, he was on an organised tour,
lots of bikes, was telling of being stopped as may as three times a day, and the cops radioing ahead to inform others of the cash rolling into town.
there are six of us, prob a good idea to travel in two groups and catch up at regular intervals.
thanks, paul.

Tirpse 6 Mar 2011 12:21

Quote:

Originally Posted by colebatch (Post 326881)
Fortunately in Russia there are two advantages to being caught breaking road rules than in your home country:
(1) You dont lose any points
(2) You get the option of paying a 50% reduced penalty if you pay direct to the policeman, and dont ask for a receipt.

I belive those two things work however option three is not to pay any unlegal bribes to officers (which encourages to continue it) on the road and not to speak russian and pretend you dont understand anything. I was stopped last summer when i turned over white line when i was leaving petrol station.

I spoke only finnish, refused to pay sum of 150 euros or 1500 USD on the road to the police and after some time police realised they are not getting any money from me, the paperwork they have to do to do it officially takes too much time and they told me to get of out the car and not to do it again.

T.REX63 6 Mar 2011 12:35

Quote:

Originally Posted by Tirpse (Post 326966)
...
I was stopped last summer when i turned over white line when i was leaving petrol station.
...

So, if I understand correctly, you already break the law of the "white line" if you ride along and turn into a gas station on the left side? (i.e. requiring a left turn over a white line, and back out again...?) :(

colebatch 6 Mar 2011 12:45

Quote:

Originally Posted by geordy paul (Post 326944)
thanks for the replies,
eased a few concerns, one guy i spoke to, he was on an organised tour,
lots of bikes, was telling of being stopped as may as three times a day, and the cops radioing ahead to inform others of the cash rolling into town.
there are six of us, prob a good idea to travel in two groups and catch up at regular intervals.
thanks, paul.

Just dont break the road rules, and you will only ever be stopped for document checks. If your docs are in order, and you dont break the road rules, then you wont have a problem with the cops.

Another tip ... respect the traffic cops. No-one likes them, but dont give them lip or attitude. They do have the power to make your life unpleasant if they think you are trying to make life difficult for them. People who are polite to cops (anywhere in the world for that matter) are less likely to have issues with them in the longer run. Common sense really.

colebatch 6 Mar 2011 12:47

Quote:

Originally Posted by T.REX63 (Post 326969)
So, if I understand correctly, you already break the law of the "white line" if you ride along and turn into a gas station on the left side? (i.e. requiring a left turn over a white line, and back out again...?) :(

Correct. If there is a solid white line, you can NOT cross it. If there is a solid line in the middle of the highway next to a petrol station then only traffic on that same side of the road can use it. You might be able to go down the road 500 yards and see a gap in the white line, then you can do a U-Turn there and go back to the petrol station. If you are unlucky there may be no gap in the white line for 10 km. Thats the breaks

colebatch 6 Mar 2011 13:01

Quote:

Originally Posted by Tirpse (Post 326966)
I belive those two things work however option three is not to pay any unlegal bribes to officers (which encourages to continue it) on the road and not to speak russian and pretend you dont understand anything. I was stopped last summer when i turned over white line when i was leaving petrol station.

I spoke only finnish, refused to pay sum of 150 euros or 1500 USD on the road to the police and after some time police realised they are not getting any money from me, the paperwork they have to do to do it officially takes too much time and they told me to get of out the car and not to do it again.

I have done this on occasion in Russia too but I dont like to do it, am not proud of doing it and I dont agree with it on principle.

I think if you break the rules, and the police catch you breaking the rules, then you are due to pay a penalty - anywhere in the world.

Being dishonest and pretending not to understand what they are saying, or dishonestly pretending you didn't know you did something wrong when you know you did, is hardly principled behaviour either.

The reality is Police there get pretty low wages, and the state de facto recognises that they get much of their income via "tips". If you get pulled over for something you plainly didnt do, and the offence is made up, then thats one thing. But if you have broken the road laws, and you know it, and they catch you out ... then you owe someone a fine. Whether its the state (who would then pay it back to the Police via higher wages) or you pay it directly to the Police ... i.e. whether you pay the police indirectly (like in the west) or directly (like in Russia) ... I dont see a big difference.

The difference to me is did you commit the offence or not - not whether you pay the police directly or indirectly. If you are 100% sure that you did not commit an offence, then by all means stand your ground, refuse to pay, act ignorant etc. But if you know you have broken the traffic laws ... then you have broken the traffic laws. You have to shrug your shoulders and say "he got me - he won that round"

Dont get me wrong, I am no goody two shoes on Russian roads ... sometimes I dont feel like taking the risk and sit on 95 km/h by my GPS. Sometimes I feel like blasting along ... but if I blast along the road, I know I am gambling 500 rubles and have it ready in my pocket in case I do get caught.

As for crossing white lines ... Its obviously been targetted by the Russian authorities as a high risk activity, presumably because many accidents have resulted from it. The police have a perfectly legitimate interest therefore in trying to enforce that rule. As in any country, the means of enforcement is by penalising drivers who break the rule. You may not like who you pay the penalty to, but the job of enforcing the road rules is a perfectly legitimate one, as is the practise of extracting financial penalties from those caught breaking the rules.

Financial penalties for breaking road rules is pretty standard global practise as a deterrent to stop people breaking those road rules in future.

I dont feel that westerners should think they can ride through Russia with some sort of immunity from road rules (especially on the grounds that they dont like the payment system) - or with the belief that ignorance of the local road rules is some form of defence. As in any country in the world, its theoretically the responsibility of the visiting driver / rider to make himself aware of the local road rules and penalties.

If you do the crime, you have to be prepared to do the time.

I dont think Russian drivers in Finland can break the road rules and expect extra leniency from the Finnish police compared to Finnish drivers. Similarly I dont think Finnish drivers should expect to be treated any differently to Russian drivers in Russia. And a Russian driver, in your case, would have been required to "pay the penalty".

henryuk 6 Mar 2011 16:27

I got stopped a lot on my last trip (mainly 'stans and russia). I found that taking your glove and helmet off and shaking hands straight away went a long way. I also carried a bit of map that had my whole route on it so I could explain what I was up to, didn't speak the language and was patient.
Twice they wouldn't let me go on without paying a fine, which was haggled down to around 5 dollars each time, and twice they bought me lunch so I reckon the tactic 'broke even'.

rusty max 6 Mar 2011 17:24

traffic rules
 
Paul,

same old story, all over again. Just stick to the rules and the likely hood of having problems is minute. Nothing has changed. Home and abroad.
Very simple and for everyone easy to understand.

Cheers

Helgo

colebatch 6 Mar 2011 17:40

Ural Mountains
 
If you go through the Ural mountains on any of the highways, you will be stuck behind slow trucks most of the time. Overtaking lanes are few. There as many speed restrictions and there is no overtaking for the majority of the way between Ufa and Chelyabinsk. Its very easy to get frustrated and try and zip past some trucks in a no overtaking zone there.

Either set yourself to relax mode and take it particularly easy crossing the Urals, or try and choose some quiet backroads. ... or else have your wallet ready.

Its a common trip up point crossing Russia. But the speed restrictions and no overtaking zones are there because there are a lot of accidents there - precisely by drivers who zoom past trucks in no overtaking zones. In fact you will see them zooming at you from the opposite direction and pulling back into their lanes just before they hit you. And you will curse them for overtaking in no overtaking zones and their unsafe driving. When you see all of that, you understand why they have no overtaking there and you see why the police are all over that section of road trying to enforce it.

motoreiter 6 Mar 2011 19:33

Quote:

Originally Posted by Tirpse (Post 326966)
I...refused to pay sum of 150 euros or 1500 USD on the road to the police and after some time police realised they are not getting any money from me...

Yikes, if anyone is paying anything like that kind of money, they are doing something terribly wrong. For speeding, probably 500-1000 rubles ($17-34), for white line violations probably 1500-2000 rubles ($50-65). All of these could go up or down a bit depending on the individual police officer. Russians lose their licenses for several months for white line violations, so it is serious stuff for the Russian police.

Once I was ticketed for a white line violation for passing a tractor that was going about 10kph along a perfectly straight, flat road...I wouldn't be surprised if the cops had a deal with the tractor driver to drive back and forth along that stretch of road...

The only way you'd be looking at $1500 is for something like driving "drunk" (which in Russia means with ANY alchohol in your breath), and even that might not get you off the hook. Just don't do it!

Tirpse 6 Mar 2011 20:01

Colebach, i totally agree that if i break rules i pay BUT i pay when i am handed out official ticket. I am not paying money when sum is written to piece of cardboard and then added with handsign rubbing of index finger and thumb showing to pay bribe and when sum goes up first from 5000 rubls to 150 euros to 1500 usd (as it went in my case)

Police was asking bribes, if they would have written me ticket on the road i would have gone to city to pay it to bank (as there is one month paying time).

Actually i was pretty straight with driving rules, didnt do much speeding, my average driving speed was something between 90-95 km/h for whole trip from Baikal to Finland and i didnt pass traffic during white lines.

When i left petrol station and turned to left over white line i didnt knew that you cant turn to left there but you have to drive right and do U turn to go to left. There was two russian car before me doing same thing so did not even thought its illegal (they were also stopped to same place)

I think this rule is very much Russian driving rule and in Finland for cases like that we have this sign to show its not allowed to turn left.
http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedi...ty_332.svg.png

But like i said if i would have shown official traffic violation ticket i would have paid it and sum police was asking was about double the price of violation i would have needed to pay officially.

I think people generally should be very causious not to pay any bribes on the road as it encourages that kind of action. If russian police is caught taking bribes on the road it means he/she is out of work. Currently it is practise what Russian police force is trying to stop.

Tirpse 6 Mar 2011 20:07

Quote:

Originally Posted by colebatch (Post 326973)
Correct. If there is a solid white line, you can NOT cross it. If there is a solid line in the middle of the highway next to a petrol station then only traffic on that same side of the road can use it. You might be able to go down the road 500 yards and see a gap in the white line, then you can do a U-Turn there and go back to the petrol station. If you are unlucky there may be no gap in the white line for 10 km. Thats the breaks

Yes that was my case.

Funny thing though is that i should have drive roughly 20 meters to right and then do U turn over line and it would have been legal. I wonder what they have been thinking when they have made that rule.

motoreiter 6 Mar 2011 20:31

Quote:

Originally Posted by Tirpse (Post 327025)
I wonder what they have been thinking when they have made that rule.

Many Russian rules are like that, but the traffic police (and border agents, etc.) are there to enforce the rules, not to make them.

And as to your point that this is "very much a Russian driving rule...", well yes, but then again you are in Russia...

Tirpse 6 Mar 2011 20:49

Quote:

Originally Posted by motoreiter (Post 327027)
Many Russian rules are like that, but the traffic police (and border agents, etc.) are there to enforce the rules, not to make them.

Ofcourse and i dont blame them for doing their work but when it turns into illegal activity then i stop to co-operate and i advice everyone else to do it as it just encourages it and causes more troubles for other incoming drivers as they see western drivers as moving payday.

To get back to original topic my advice to all people going to Russia is
1. Follow rules and you will be fine
2. If you break rule and you are stopped by police dont panic
3. Never ever pay anything to police on the road. Its illegal and against the law. Money goes straight to policeman pocket. If you break traffic rule or any other rule they always need to give you ticket from your violation what you pay to bank.
4. You have one month time to pay the fine to bank as its only place where to pay it.
5. If policeman is keeping your paper and insist you to pay your fines on the road i would start to look my embassy/consulate number to my mobile.

Nath 6 Mar 2011 21:14

Quote:

Originally Posted by colebatch (Post 326976)
But if you have broken the road laws, and you know it, and they catch you out ... then you owe someone a fine.

Bullshit. If it's a stupid rule serving absolutely no purpose, then most people would agree you should break it if you can away with it. Leading from this, if you get caught but can escape being penalised, then good for you.

If the police pulled you and tried to penalise you for some ludicrous traffic violation in your home country, then I'm sure you'd either try and argue it out with them or get out of it on a technicality or any other means possible. So why behave differently in a foreign country?

T.REX63 6 Mar 2011 22:50

Quote:

Originally Posted by Nath (Post 327036)
...
So why behave differently in a foreign country?

Because you are in a foreign country...:yes:

OEhman 7 Mar 2011 05:03

I Have been stopped numerous times by the Russian police and have been forced to pay them off two times.

The first time I'm pretty sure that I went back to my lane before the white line started but i still got stopped. I was new and green to paying the police off and they where pretty scary. The whole thing took maybe half an hour of negotiating even if I don't really speak Russian and spoke even less at that time. They showed me a report they had already filled in with someones Russian drivers license paper clipped to it and showed me both the report they where going to write for me and a temporary drivers license they where going to issue me. At that time I paid but today i would have asked to see the evidence I believe they have to shoot in such serious offenses.

Second time was also about the same kind of offense. There was maybe 30 cars driving behind a lorry at about 50km/h and when the white line stopped i went for a takeover and wondered why only one car was overtaking with me. There must have been a temporary sign prohibiting takeovers that I missed. Same thing, they where clearly professionals in scaring people. Both of these incidents happened east of the Ural mountains, around Tatarstan.

One time I met some German travelers and we decided to camp in the forests somewhere between Omsk and Novosibirsk IIRC. Not generally a good idea nor recommended but we survived. In the morning I left a minute before the guys because i wanted to travel alone. Just a few kilometers from where we camped I was stopped at a police station. He asked for my documents and as he was looking at them the Germans arrived too and got stopped as well. The police asked something including the word "kamrad" (friend) and answered him niet, "No".

He gave me my documents back while he checked the German guys paperwork. I did not want to leave until i get a clear sign for that so I stayed there. He spotted what he thought was some kind of offense in their visa registration and started questioning them about that. They did either not understand anything of what he said or then they did just not want to understand, but I did a mistake by telling them in English what the problem was. A mistake. He wanted them to follow him to the police station and as they left I asked him what about me. He showed me to follow. We were put in a cell but the door was left open, so after maybe half a minute we decided to go outside to the beautiful morning showing no fear for them. After a few minutes the police finally arrived with their passports and let us go.

One interesting thing was that when we were leaving they shouted something after us through the window. One of the German guys went there and got a book that turned out to be the new testament in Russian. No idea why they gave that. But the lesson of the story is to keep calm and show respect but no fear for the police. They probably hoped for us to hand over some dollars immediately when we were put in the cell.

I have also been stopped two times for speeding, once for 120 in 90 and once for about 75 in 50 and both times they have let me go immediately when i they realized I'm a tourist. So speeding does not matter, passing a white line does. Don't do that.

motoreiter 7 Mar 2011 07:13

Quote:

Originally Posted by Nath (Post 327036)
Bullshit. If it's a stupid rule serving absolutely no purpose, then most people would agree you should break it if you can away with it.

Good luck with that approach in Russia, I would bring lots of cash...

And kudos to you for having the higher intellect to be able to determine what is a "stupid rule" that shouldn't be followed vs a "pain in the ass, but perhaps necessary rule" that should be followed, such fine distinctions escape me.

For instance, I consider Russia's "zero tolerance" rule for alcohol and driving to be "stupid" but gee, maybe they know better what driving rules should be adopted and enforced. Ya think?

motoreiter 7 Mar 2011 07:25

Quote:

Originally Posted by OEhman (Post 327085)
We were put in a cell but the door was left open, so after maybe half a minute we decided to go outside to the beautiful morning showing no fear for them. After a few minutes the police finally arrived with their passports and let us go...They probably hoped for us to hand over some dollars immediately when we were put in the cell.

This is exactly the kind of thing that gets blown way out of proportion. Pretty soon we'll be reading distorted reports based on your post about tourists being locked into cells with convicted murderers until they paid $1000, etc.

I don't mean to criticize you for posting this, actually it is an interesting story and a useful example. And while I wasn't there and so could be missing some important context, I don't know if it is fair to assume that they put you in the cell to get money from you. If that was the case, I think they'd have certainly locked the door? Who knows, maybe they didn't have anywhere else to put you, or SOP in that detachment was to put everyone in the cell until further notice, they were having a birthday party in the usual waiting room, etc. It is not as if these stations are large, well-planned facilities. The fact that they gave you a bible seems to indicate that they didn't have hostile intentions.

I don't mean to be always sticking up for the Russian police, I have met some right fine bastards among them, but many stories are way overblown and based on misunderstandings on both sides due to lack of a common language. I just hate to see people scared of coming to Russia because of fear of police, it is a serious overreaction.

ilesmark 7 Mar 2011 09:57

Entertaining thread!!

I was caught breaking the law 6 times in Russia and Kaz (speeding or overtaking) and twice they just wanted to give me words of advice, but 4 times they wanted to bust me and couldn't because I couldn't speak Russian - HA!

Also - don't fall foul of visa registration rules ie register within 2 (or is it 3?) business days of entering Russia, then again if you're in any 1 place for more than 3 days. I entered Russia through Vladivostok and had to stay there for 2 weeks awaiting my car (shipping and customs delays). I had stayed in a hotel for the first night and had asked them to register my visa. They apparently did so, but I wasn't given any stamp on my immigration card (and didn't know one was needed). The first time I was aware of any problem was when I tried to stay in a hotel in Khabarovsk and got refused because my visa hadn't been registered. After this I called the British Embassy in Moscow and they explained about the registration system. It was they who advised me to start keeping receipts from roadhouses / hotels / filling stations as an 'audit trail' to show where I'd been and on which days to prove I hadn't been in any 1 place long enough to need to re-register my visa. They also told me to expect trouble when I left Russia as I hadn't registered my visa properly in Vladivostok. That being said, none of the frequent police stops I had to make for document inspections ever gave me any trouble about the missing registration stamp on my immigation card.

When I drove to the Omsk border with Kazakhstan, the guards seemed to take a liking to me and one of them stuck his head around the door of the passport control and said something to the woman. I don't know if that helped, but I wasn't given any hassle about my visa.

A month later, I re-entered Russia through the Orsk crossing. This time I kept receipts right from the start AND registered my visa properly with a stamp on my immigation card. About 10 days before I left Russia, I was near Red Square with a German when we both got stopped by the tourist police. I was able to prove with my wad of receipts that I hadn't been in Moscow for long enough to need to register my visa there (or indeed any other part of Russia); the German didn't have any proof and had to pay a 500 rouble bribe.

1 very minor suggestion - have all your papers in a clear plastic wallet ready for when you get stopped for frequent dokumenty inspecty and proffer it out the window as soon as you stop. Makes it look like you've nothing to hide and speeds things up.

Mark

overlandcruiser.net

Nath 7 Mar 2011 20:44

Quote:

Originally Posted by motoreiter (Post 327097)
For instance, I consider Russia's "zero tolerance" rule for alcohol and driving to be "stupid" but gee, maybe they know better what driving rules should be adopted and enforced. Ya think?

No, I don't think they necessarily know better. Like I said, If I don't agree with the rule and wish to break it, the factor that determines my actions is the likelyhood of getting caught. Various times drank one or more beers then got on the bike whilst I was in Russia. I made judgements at the time (which may not have been accurate) that I was unlikely to get caught.

I break the speed limit constantly whilst riding the bike here in the UK at the moment. I'm having a good run, done about 50,000 miles over the last year and not got into any trouble with the old bill. If I thought the government/police 'knew better' I would be driving everywhere sticking to the speed limits.

Jake 7 Mar 2011 21:45

Hey Nath your blog is interesting - But it seems a shame you have such anger and a lot of the rebel still burning in you - you seem to have learnt little from your travels - usually lets you open your mind a bit.
I don't really agree with your views on rules and you knowing best - But hey ho everyone to their own way !.
Some may say your disregard will knock onto the next guy travelling through where ever - but I suppose that's not really your problem.
I do often wonder with viewpoints like yours where there is such disregard for authority where ever it may be - if and when the shite really hit the fan and you end up in some far off police cell, or maybe one of them corrupt officials trying to keep you alive at the side of the road after a bad off,or maybe stuck in a hospital bed seriously injured - would you stick to your guns and not ask help from anyone in authority (ie embassy etc) to maybe give you legal advice, interpreter, repatriation or anything else you may need when everything else has fallen apart.
It just appears to me that here in the nanny state we have where views can be voiced you often see those that protest against authorities the most - shout even louder when they feel they are hard done too, missing out or needing help.
Be interesting to see where you stand on the views of authorities helping you when your in need, . Its no problem to me either way - not my life - but always wonder where you might be sitting on the fence when the cards are down.

OEhman 7 Mar 2011 22:58

Quote:

Originally Posted by motoreiter (Post 327098)
This is exactly the kind of thing that gets blown way out of proportion. Pretty soon we'll be reading distorted reports based on your post about tourists being locked into cells with convicted murderers until they paid $1000, etc.

I don't mean to criticize you for posting this, actually it is an interesting story and a useful example. And while I wasn't there and so could be missing some important context, I don't know if it is fair to assume that they put you in the cell to get money from you. If that was the case, I think they'd have certainly locked the door? Who knows, maybe they didn't have anywhere else to put you

The place was just a normal roadside police "control post" or what they are called in English. The cell was the first room after the entrance so yes, if they absolutely wanted us inside the building for some reason it was the easiest place to put us even if a cell gives you a pretty bad feeling.

But yes, they did never ask for any money or anything else, they just had the idea that their registration was too late and spent some time inside the police station with their documents. It's possible that they used that time to check what the rules are and found out that everything is in order.

The reason I posted it is pretty much to tell people to keep calm and wait and see what's happening. The way the police operate over there is a bit different to Europe but things have a tendency to sort out even if the situation feels bad.

Most of the contacts with the police in Russia are just regular stops to see your documents. At worst I have been stopped four times in one day. Usually they are just curious and want to know from where you are where you are heading. After my first trip I bought a A5 sized book with ten transparent pockets so i have all my vehicle documents and Russian documents available for easy viewing. Highly recommended.

Nath 8 Mar 2011 00:28

Hey adventure950,
Your post is a little strange, I'm not sure where you got the idea from that I'm brimming with anger held against 'authority'? I simply do not feel obliged to blindly obey traffic rules/laws (and to some extent rules/laws in general). If you ever break speed limits then you are hypocritical to condemn me for this opinion.

My original post was with regards to what happens when you get caught by the old bill. Colebatch said he thought you should cough up straight away, that it's immoral to try and sit it out, wait to be let off. I don't agree with this at all. If they're trying to penalise you for a technicality, then it's fair game to try and wriggle out of it however.

Quote:

Some may say your disregard will knock onto the next guy travelling through where ever - but I suppose that's not really your problem.
Some would say that your eagerness to break out the 100 dollar notes the moment a policeman stops you and accuses you of a traffic rule infringement, "will knock onto the next guy travelling through where ever", but I suppose if he doesn't have the same unlimited depth wallet as you that's not really your problem.


For the record, I never had any difficulties with Russian police, the only encounters I had with Russian traffic coppers were pulling over at their checkpoints to ask them directions. I am only able to say from these encounters that they were fairly polite and helpful. In central Asia however I got stopped numerous times by dodgey coppers trying to accuse me of made up offences asking for money. I never payed any of them a penny, and all of them were quite friendly and cheerful when eventually letting me go - Obviously there are enough 'two wheeled cash machines' out there to make trying it on a a lighthearted but worthwhile affair for them.

Jake 8 Mar 2011 06:54

Hey Nath, grand, I like the reply a bit more balanced, unlike your previous postings (21 and 27) or maybe I picked up your previous posting wrong - but you do sound angry and certainly rebelious -if i got you wrong -.sorry but you did come across pretty heavy in the way you worded them for that I make my apology. The way you have worded your stuff this time makes the reading much easier and you come across a bit better - As for speeding yes I have in the past - oh the folly of youth ! and at times paid the price not only financially but also in some pretty big injuries and bent bike. However no doubt I will speed a little - here at home where I know the area well, the road well and am well experienced in the way things work, (well if the bilge pump can wind herself up quick enough to get there - that would be some achievement eh!) -(bilge pump being my old r80gs) but if I am caught - then fair play I take it on the nose as for the other rules of the road I stick to them here and abroad always do - i don't want to cause myself or anyone else hassle or a problem - so I don't feel too hypocritical on our difference of opinion. Nor do I accept that laws/rules (mainly on the road) have no reason or purpose, I generally accept they are there for some reason however obscure they may appear to me or anyone else. I agree with you on not paying bribes and so far never have but also have never been pushed on that one, so on the day depending on the circumstances I maybe might stay open and flexible on that viewpoint. Still it be good stuff to debate over after a few bier and then put the whole world back on track. Regards Jake.

T.REX63 8 Mar 2011 23:28

Aside from fines being justified or not, I believe the moment you leave your home country and venture abroad, you become an ambassador of your home country, your culture and, in our case, the motorcycle riding community.

I find it somewhat sad if this is overlooked for selfish reasons. And, no, one does not have to put up with nonsense either. But, there are ways to go about it. Acting stupid or ignorant is not one of the ways I would consider.

...just saying :(

motoreiter 9 Mar 2011 04:04

Quote:

Originally Posted by Nath (Post 327265)
In central Asia however I got stopped numerous times by dodgey coppers trying to accuse me of made up offences asking for money. I never payed any of them a penny, and all of them were quite friendly and cheerful when eventually letting me go - Obviously there are enough 'two wheeled cash machines' out there to make trying it on a a lighthearted but worthwhile affair for them.

Before you hurt your arm patting yourself on the back, I thought I'd point out that:
--no one has ever recommended paying "dodgey coppers" for "made up offences". Most people correctly resist paying in those circumstances; and
--the reason that Central Asian police were probably so friendly was not because there are so many "two wheeled cash machines" (how many foreign motorcyclists do you think the average Uzbek policeman sees in a year?), but because the whole thing was a lark from the beginning, their only cost was a few minutes of their time.

Also, I just want to say again that it is really not a good idea to drink and ride and Russia. You didn't get caught, but I can tell you from personal experience that they seem to focus more on checking motorcyclists than drivers, at all times of day (presumably because they assume motorcyclists like to party). And getting busted for having any alcohol in you is guaranteed to ruin your day...

Knight of the Holy Graal 9 Mar 2011 10:28

Quote:

Originally Posted by motoreiter (Post 327458)
they seem to focus more on checking motorcyclists than drivers, at all times of day (presumably because they assume motorcyclists like to party).


I begin to worry for my trip to Samarkand of end of June.

Even if I don't drink and drive, my biker vest that I always wear when riding has some enamel pins that may be... suspect :(: Guinness, Kilkenny, Newcastle Brown Ale, Duvel...
Better to REMOVE BEFORE FLIGHT! :mchappy:


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 14:40.


vB.Sponsors