Horizons Unlimited - The HUBB

Horizons Unlimited - The HUBB (https://www.horizonsunlimited.com/hubb/)
-   BMW Tech (https://www.horizonsunlimited.com/hubb/bmw-tech/)
-   -   TKC80 dangerous wear pattern (https://www.horizonsunlimited.com/hubb/bmw-tech/tkc80-dangerous-wear-pattern-73738)

Roboyobo 24 Dec 2013 19:09

TKC80 dangerous wear pattern
 
My front wheel has suddenly started to slide around on corners in a more than exciting manner (on an R100GSPD with standard forks and wheels).

Looking at the TKC80 on the front I can see why. The knobs of tread have worn in a very uneven pattern, with some down to less than 1 mm and others barely worn. There is no common direction in which the wear is lying. Knobs that are right next to each other are worn in different ways and different directions.

It looks as if the contact patch of the tyre has been dangerously reduced.

The tyre has done about 2000 miles. I usually expect at least 3000.

Anyone else had this happen?

I'll be switching to Karoo 3 now. I think they have more rigidity, which might help.

Endurodude 24 Dec 2013 20:35

I've never used the TKC due to the fast wear rate, but I had the exact same thing happen to a front Mitas E10 I used over the Summer. I had some VERY scary moments where the tyre steered itself! The worst time was on a motorway coming down a mountain!

mollydog 24 Dec 2013 22:20

An Odd one Dec. 24th, 14:15 hrs.
 
Some pics would really help with this one. Hard to describe uneven tire wear. PICS !!

I've used TKC's on two of my bikes (not BMW's) ... never have had the radical uneven wear you describe. The rears do wear fast on pavement, the fronts last 3 times as long.

The one in pic below is from my DR650 (about 390 lbs. fully fueled and loaded) About 1500 miles on this tire. It's wearing quite well, about 800 miles tarmac, 700 miles dirt. Wearing perfectly! (PS: I never balance my wheels)

https://lh5.googleusercontent.com/-2...0/P1000193.JPG
TKC80 front at 1500 miles. (90/90-21)

I've seen TKC fronts wear badly on a RTW R100GS (and other bikes) ... Some of the R100's were ridden on almost ALL paved roads ... so center wear was quite pronounced but wear was fairly even, save the unworn knobs on the side of the tire, which were still in fair shape.

Really the WRONG tire for paved roads ... and can be dangerous on wet, greasy roads, especially if over inflated. :helpsmilie: (I've seen a couple R1150GS riders GO DOWN running TKC's in wet. Not good)

Tire pressures are important and a wobbly wheel could also cause funny wear patterns. But you should feel this when riding if out of alignment or wobbling at various speeds.

Maybe try a nice 50/50 tire if riding at least 50% tarmac? (Heidenau, Shinko,
Kenda, Mefo et al)

*Touring Ted* 24 Dec 2013 23:22

Nothing new with these tyres... It comes from long stretches on tarmac. There is no need for TKC's unless you're going to hit the trails..

Hiendenau K60's are better... My front lasted 30,000 miles and was still legal... Crazy !!

chris 25 Dec 2013 08:52

Imho tkc80s are sh!te. I've experienced quite a few. Weird wear patterns, short life, huge expense compared to better rubber like the Heidenau k60 that is as aggressive/ useful off road as the Conti but doesn't have the "rugged adventure look".

*Touring Ted* 25 Dec 2013 09:16

Quote:

Originally Posted by chris (Post 447985)
Imho tkc80s are sh!te. I've experienced quite a few. Weird wear patterns, short life, huge expense compared to better rubber like the Heidenau k60 that is as aggressive/ useful off road as the Conti but doesn't have the "rugged adventure look".

CHRIS.... HOW CAN YOU SAY THAT.....

They're BMW approved fitment :smartass:

And BMW knows best... doh

chris 25 Dec 2013 18:01

Quote:

Originally Posted by *Touring Ted* (Post 447987)
CHRIS.... HOW CAN YOU SAY THAT.....

They're BMW approved fitment :smartass:

And BMW knows best... doh

In the spirit of goodwill to all men on this auspicious 25th December, I am unable to comment further on the topic of BMW approved anything. :innocent:

Drinking Efes pilsner at Olympos near Kemer in Turkey instead.

Roboyobo 25 Dec 2013 19:12

I've been using TKC80s since 2008. They've been very good, although short-lived. On the R100GSPD they usually give excellent grip on the road. In deep sand or mud they are near to miraculous.

The reason I switched to TKC80 was that I had a Tourance front tyre disintegrate through to the carcass on a long trip, even though the rest of the tyre had plenty of tread depth. That was after using Tourance for many years. I noted at the time that Metzeler had switched production from Germany to Brazil.

Tyre quality does seem to vary considerably, even with the same type of tyre.

Roboyobo 25 Dec 2013 19:15

Back to the original issue: this pattern of wear is very odd, with tread knobs worn in a seemingly random pattern.

Can anyone suggest a cause other than stating that TKC80s are rubbish? (in my experience they are good).

cchoc 25 Dec 2013 22:37

Out of balance?

*Touring Ted* 25 Dec 2013 23:57

Excuse the pun... But it's just the way they roll. In a rotation, only certain parts of the tyre contacts the tarmac. Its the fronts that tend to go weird... I wouldn't worry about it too much..

Sent from my XT1032 using Tapatalk

IanJ 26 Dec 2013 00:49

Greetings Roboyobo

I'm curious, are you able to post or put up a link to a photo of your worn tyre?

I have/had a pair of TKC80 on my R100GSPD and I didn't see any sign of the wear you describe , but then again I have just had to replace the front tyre down here in Ushuaia due to a split puncture that screwed the tyre.

What sort of roads were you riding and what tyre pressures were you running?

Regards

Ian J

marcm 26 Dec 2013 09:30

Most of the more dirt orientated tyres will do it on hard surfaces for long enough,recently took the Pirelli mt21 off front of my tenere that had every other block worn away,had ridden it back from Spain like it,just have to aware the steering can be a little odd..bit like the owner realy so not a major problem...

Globetrotter 26 Dec 2013 10:46

Tkc 80
 
It's the normal wear pattern for this tyre. I went through several TKC 80 on my trip around the world with my AT750. I tried with different air pressure, sometimes even changed the tyre direction on the rim in order for the knobblies not to wear evenly. Nothing really helped. If you stay offroad it won't happen...
In my opinion the TKC 80 are too expensive. There are alternatives out there which cost less and do the job.
See: Reifen Statistik
here some other proplem I encounterd with this tyre and it happened more than once:
http://flic.kr/p/iCEYrd
and
http://flic.kr/p/iCEYCW


Greets

Claudio

Magnon 26 Dec 2013 11:31

I agree that it is the normal wear pattern in my experience. I've had a couple of sets on my R100GS and they have both done this to some extent. I notice they are noisy on very hot tarmac (air temp >35C) and have put some of this excessive wear down to that.

I've used Pirelli MT21 on other bikes and have seen similar wear but then these bikes have very effective single disc brakes (unlike the R100GS).

Redboots 26 Dec 2013 19:10

Does it look like this?

http://bikerbytes.com/images/tkc.jpg

This was a new tyre fitted in France. Halfway across Kazakhstan it looked like this. On my mates bike, same model r100GS, the tyre was evenly worn.

What was different? He had no front brake. The caliper blew in Germany and he had to ride to China before we could replace it.
So it seems the blocks squirm and move under braking on sealed roads that cause the wear.

Now you know how to stop it happening:clap:

Roboyobo 27 Dec 2013 08:33

That's exactly what it's like, but a bit more extreme. And the handling is terrible.

As i said, i've been using TKC80 for a long time, on and off road, in all conditions, for short and long rides. I've never had trouble before. I did a ride through the mountains in Wales in torrential rain, all OK. Then suddenly, very suddenly, it started to slide on corners in the dry.

I had a quiet year, with only a couple of short road trips. The tyre might have actually done less than 1000.

Threewheelbonnie 27 Dec 2013 08:45

As a former brake engineer who has the sense to only pick fights with the tyre people after extensive investigation, that wear pattern looks to me like the contact patch was not presented evenly to the road. First thought then is to put more air in. Maybe this is why Heidenau use such stiff walls on the K60?

Andy

STG06 27 Dec 2013 17:22

Continental?
 
I remember seeing a Continental Tire rep at HUBB UK this year. Perhaps this could be responded to by the makers of the tire as I know I've seen the same weird wear patterns on the TKCs I've had on the KLR. Only the front though. Must be some clear explanation available somewhere...
Stephen

AliBaba 27 Dec 2013 17:37

Quote:

Originally Posted by Redboots (Post 448120)
Does it look like this?

http://bikerbytes.com/images/tkc.jpg

This was a new tyre fitted in France. Halfway across Kazakhstan it looked like this. On my mates bike, same model r100GS, the tyre was evenly worn.

What was different? He had no front brake. The caliper blew in Germany and he had to ride to China before we could replace it.
So it seems the blocks squirm and move under braking on sealed roads that cause the wear.

Now you know how to stop it happening:clap:

Yes, braking kills them. Drive smooth and they last for a long time.
I've had MT21 last for 18kkm, but it's easy to kill it in a day:frown:

chris 3 Jan 2014 09:08

Just finishing a loop from/to Bulgaria via Greece and Turkey on an old Transalp. Running tkc80 front and rear (from a stash when they were cheaper and I thought I needed the look).

The back has done 2000 km and is on half life. The front has done 5000 km and has the same weird wear pattern as shown in the picture above = shagged. Easy pavement riding, a bit of gravel, solo and 2 up, cold weather (about 15 degrees c) and a useless front brake.

As suggested above, imho, for the now premium price, this product is shite. Another 800 clicks back to Bulgaria and I'll swap it for a k60. Half the price and lasts 4x as long and as good on and off pavement as the Conti.

An aside: the mitas eo9 has a similar tread pattern to the tkc80 and is much better value. Can't have a worse reputation, can it?

Roboyobo 3 Jan 2014 18:41

As I said, I've used TKC80s for many miles, on tarmac, gravel, mud and some sand, and not had a problem. That includes a fast ride through to Romania and back through the Alps. Always at 2.5 bar front, 2.8 back. Always ridden very smoothly. Always giving good even grip over 3000 miles. It's just this one tyre that has gone bad.

I've now got Avon Gripsters. OE fitment on the '93 R100GSPD. As suggested by one of the best BMW mechanics in the UK (or perhaps the best).

*Touring Ted* 3 Jan 2014 20:05

TKC's are SOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO 2005. Tote's last gen... :rofl:


K60's are what the cool kids all have now.

I mean, TKC's are an approved option on BMW's. That's just how UNCOOL they are :innocent:

Threewheelbonnie 4 Jan 2014 08:43

So, I was cool in 2005 and still have it. :thumbup1:

Probably makes up for 1995 when putting Heidenaus on MZ's to replace OEM Pneumats was anything but!

:rofl:

Andy

Roboyobo 5 Jan 2014 20:17

The Avon Gripsters are fine. I went out in the ice last night, and they are nice and grippy, running predictably on corners. Just right. So, sorry, i'm just not "cooooool", whatever that's all about.

flyred 22 Feb 2014 16:49

Agree on the weird wear pattern of the TKC80. I could get 9000 miles out of the front tire if I kept the speed down below 65mph. It was gone in 3000 miles if I went much faster on my 990ADV. Once it wears like that mine would start hopping below 55 mph and no balancing would correct it. I still love the TKC80 as a great all terrain tire.


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 18:44.


vB.Sponsors