Are BMW expandable aluminium bags good enough for RWT
 

Hello gurus,

Are the F650GS BMW bags (which I already have) good enough, or should I invest in a set of Jessy panniers?

Has anyone taken the BMW OEM bags on extended trips over rough roads?

I'd appreciate your opinions on this subject.

Sorry, that should have been RTW instead of RWT.

Take a look at this link.......
http://www.advrider.com/forums/showthread.php?t=6614

Thanks, Dizzie.

Exactly what I was looking for.

Trekkingbee

The 1150GS plastic cases are fine (if the space is enough for you) but the F650 cases are flimsy. I wouldn't rely on them.
We lost a set in Turkey.</p>


OK, the left one was hit by a big coach which had its side door open and not much would have survived that. However, the impact, unsurprisingly, knocked the stationary bike over and the other pannier was rendered almost useless too.

http://www.touratech.de/shop_uk/medi...031-0_I_01.JPG

Any kind of impact can spoil the rubber seal on those expandable cases and then they're open to rain and the elements.
For what its worth, the Turkish judicial and insurance system does work (slowly) and the bike now sports much better Touratech panniers.
It's hard to stay "thin" on an F650 (the 1150 can accommodate two 35
litre panniers really well) but 35 litre cases should be space enough especially
for a lone rider.</p>

Thanks, Stephano.

It looks like I'll be ordering a set of Jesse's soon.